Taking Stock and Rethinking Artistic Research
with Mine Dogantan-Dack (Cambridge University)
Over the past decade, artistic research has become increasingly established across higher education and artistic institutions, generating a range of methodologies, practices, and claims about the kinds of knowledge artistic practice can produce. In this lecture, I will critically evaluate these developments, examining what has been achieved and what epistemological and methodological questions remain contested. In this connection, I will engage closely with the issue of subjectivity in artistic research. Artistic practice, which lies at the heart of artistic research, is a deeply situated, embodied, contingent and creative endeavour. Its core is the artist’s subjective lifeworld. Yet, subjectivity has been subject to intense critique, particularly in relation to its connection to the rigour, validity, and epistemic status of scholarly research. I will consider these tensions to explore what forms of knowledge artistic research makes possible, asking what exactly is involved in “subjectivity”, why it matters, and whether we have yet fully harnessed its potential for knowledge production in artistic research.
Artistic practice-based research in a French National Conservatoire
with Amandine Pras (CNSMD)
Whereas graduates of French National Conservatoires hold high skills in dance, music and theatre, their engagement in research presents many challenges. The Conservatoire national supérieur de musique et de danse de Paris (CNNSMDP) offers two PhD programmes, i.e., a PhD in Music – Research and Practice in partnership with Sorbonne University; and the Sciences Arts Création Recherche (SACRe) PhD that brings together seven National arts school at Paris Sciences Lettres (PSL) University. The first one lies in a musicological framework within the laboratories Institut de Recherche en Musicologie (IreMus) and Sciences et Technologies de la Musique et du Son (STMS, Ircam). The music performers of this programme need to find relevant ways to articulate their practice-based research interests with the expectations of the field. In doctoral workshops at CNSMDP, we encourage them to draw upon methods of performance studies that have received more attention abroad and that enable of bridging of practical with theoretical knowledge. SACRe started in 2012 as the first PhD programme of research creation carried by art schools in France (Mahé, 2015; Mahé & Buser, 2024). In its doctoral seminar, we inspire artists to make the most of the multidisciplinary nature of the PSL ecosystem to grasp at a range of practice-based approaches (Candy et al., 2021) that can incorporate all sorts of methods beyond the arts to construct new knowledge that emerges from a creation project. PhD students of CNSMDP have also access to the resources of the European alliance In.Tune, including courses in artistic research. Additionally, to better prepare our Master students to both of these programmes, we also develop research mentorship opportunities at CNSMDP, through assistantship of funded projects, and project-based learning environments in classes (Pras, forthcoming).
References : Candy, L., Edmonds, E., & Vear, C. (2021). Practice-based research. The Routledge international handbook of practice-based research, 27-41. / Mahé, E. (2015). Pour une recherche combinatoire : Enjeux de la recherche en art : le doctorat SACRe comme cas d’étude. Hermès, La Revue, 72(2), 217-225. / Mahé, E., & Buser, É. (2024). Le doctorat en recherche-création comme instrument d’innovation institutionnelle : un retour d’expérience sur le programme doctoral «SACRe» de l’Université PSL. Sciences du Design, 20(2), 114-132. / Pras, A. (à paraître). Le mentorat par la pratique professionnelle de la recherche, une solution pour les écoles d’art et les conservatoires nationaux supérieurs ? Actes du séminaire sur le doctorat par la pratique du 15 décembre 2025, Ministère de la culture.
Organizing the Encounter: Research, Creation, Representation
with Vincent Martos (CPGE Lycée Raspail, Paris)
Between 2023 and 2025, several release-type events were organized in the studios of IRCAM, at the intersection of research, musical creation, and technological experimentation. Drawing from this experience, the discussion aims to revisit the practical questions that arise when organizing an event within a research and creation institution.
Who should be invited? For which audience? What format should be envisioned? How can the constraints and uses of an institution be reconciled with the practices of artists and researchers? How can an initiative initially designed for staff evolve, and what might its future be beyond the event itself?
Through this specific case, the goal is to more broadly examine the conditions for the encounter between research, creation, and representation, as well as the role of spaces, devices, and institutions in facilitating their interaction.
Experimenting with Formats in Research-Creation
with Fanny Gribenski (CNRS, STMS), Jonathan Larcher (Université Paris Nanterre) and Diane Schuh (Sorbonne-Université)
Research-creation in music and sound art claims to produce knowledge through artistic practice, but this knowledge is still primarily published in written form, in books and articles. Yet part of what this research uncovers relates to the listening experience itself, which is difficult to convey in writing. This panel explores the conditions under which audio formats can become full-fledged modes of publication, either complementing writing or replacing it. We will examine three types of formats based on three projects: the documentary podcast (the “Podcast Intellectuals” program, NYU), the sound-enhanced lecture (an ethnographic study of noise pollution on the grazing lands of Sami reindeer herders in Sweden), and the sound installation (Troisième Nature, a sonification of plants’ biosignals). Each raises its own epistemological and methodological issues.
For the podcast, the tension between journalistic and scientific approaches, as well as the aesthetic exploration inherent in this format, may prove at odds with our critical ambitions.
For the sound-enhanced lecture, the balance to be struck is between sonic and ethnographic fidelity to the white noise of infrastructure and the enchantment of the listening experience—necessary to capture the audience’s attention.
For the sound installation, the issue is its reception: what visitors actually take away from it, and the risk that it may perpetuate the anthropocentric biases it seeks to challenge.
Discussing and comparing these three modes of research-creation will allow us to pose two questions: what criteria should be used to evaluate the knowledge conveyed by these formats, and how do they, in turn, transform investigative and writing practices?